• Nurses were too busy to regular check patients two nights before infant died
  • One-year-old Hayley was 'overlooked and neglected' 
  • Doctors were 'arrogant and unprofessional'
  • Parents were repeatedly told there was 'nothing to worry about'
  • Hospital apologises for not requesting treatment on Hayley soon enough
  • When family expressed concerns doctor treated them with 'utter contempt'

By Daily Mail Reporter

|

Paula Stevenson, seen here with a picture of her baby girl Hayley, describe her daughter's treatment at Birmingham Children's Hospital as 'brutal'

Paula Stevenson, seen here with a picture of her baby girl Hayley, describe her daughter's treatment at Birmingham Children's Hospital as 'brutal'


A ward nurse at a hospital where a seriously-ill baby died of heart failure has admitted staff did not follow procedure by regularly checking patients prior to the girl's death.

Hayley Fullerton died within a month of her first birthday after doctors ignored her mother's pleas to transfer the little girl to an intensive care unit.

An inquest into the infant's death today heard that when her family raised concerns with a doctor they were treated with 'utter contempt', while nurses did not fill out hourly progress charts for patients two days before Hayley died because the hospital was understaffed.

Paula Stevenson, who said her daughter was 'overlooked and neglected' at Birmingham Children's Hospital, had said she even tried to bribe a nurse with a 100 gift voucher in the hope of improving her care.

Ward nurse Jackie Clinton today told the hearing that on November 9, the day Hayley's lung collapsed, staff did not fill in hourly progress charts as required.

She also admitted under questioning that staff instead relied in monitors - which she also said were frequently ignored.

She told the inquest: 'We weren't following the procedure, on the night of the 9th of November it was very busy and one nurse was off sick.

'The nurses often have up to three patients and if they are caring for a patient in a cubicle and another child alarm sounds they know through experience whether they should attend the alarm or not.

'I think we respond to the alarms appropriately and if the parents are with the children there are emergency cords that they can pull.'

Hayley had been diagnosed with a hole in the heart before she was born, and was admitted to Birmingham Children's Hospital for corrective surgery when she was ten months old.

Miss Stevenson said that while the operation was a success, complications arose during Hayley's recovery after doctors inserted the wrong size tube into her lung, causing it to collapse.

Hayley Fullerton was born with a hole in her heart, and had to undergo surgery aged 10-months-old to correct it

It was during the recovery from the surgery when complications arose, ultimately leading to her tragic death

The inquest heard Hayley's parents became increasingly concerned that their only child was struggling to breathe and looked 'puffy' – but were repeatedly told by medics that there was nothing to worry about.

When her lung collapsed for a second time, Hayley was put in an isolation ward, despite Miss Stevenson and husband Bobby Fullerton begging doctors to transfer her to intensive care.

The couple and Hayley's grandparents, Sylvia and Edward Stevenson, kept a vigil at her bedside, but Hayley died in November 2009 – four weeks after the corrective surgery.

The hearing was also told that one of the doctors at the hospital treated Hayley's family with 'utter contempt' when they expressed concerns about her care.

Paula Stevenson told an inquest her one-year-old daughter was overlooked and neglected at the hospital

Paula Stevenson told an inquest her one-year-old daughter was overlooked and neglected at the hospital

After being informed by hospital staff that Hayley's right lung had collapsed on November 9, her grandmother, Sylvia Stevenson, who has since died, asked Dr Oliver Stumper, a paediatric cardiologist, what treatment she could be given.

The family was told that physiotherapy would be arranged for the following day, the inquest heard.

In a statement written before her death, which was read to the court yesterday, Mrs Stevenson said that Dr Stumper had 'barked' his response to her questions, adding: 'My daughter said I looked like a parent in a third world country begging for my child's life.'

Her husband Edward Stevenson told the coroner that Dr Stumper 'glared' at his wife and 'gave her a look of utter contempt' when she asked about the physiotherapy for her grand-daughter.

Hayley Fullerton with her grandparents, Edward and Sylvia Stevenson, both helped keep a bedside vigil for the four weeks Hayley spent in hospital before her death

Giving evidence at the inquest today, Dr Stumper said: 'I think we provided therapy by and large at the right time.

It was during Hayley's recovery from the surgery when complications arose, ultimately leading to her tragic death.

Hayley was born in Northern Ireland on October 6 2008 with a heart defect and a hole in the heart, and underwent palliative surgery at the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast weeks later, Birmingham Coroner's Court heard.

In October 2009 she was flown to Birmingham Children's Hospital for corrective heart surgery.

Her mother, who lives with Hayley's father Bobby Fullerton and their second daughter Casey in Australia, said the operation was a success and Hayley was transferred to the hospital's Paediatric Intensive Care Unit, where she spent 17 days before being moved onto a normal ward.

Here's what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

My heart is broken for this poor, poor woman. I cannot even begin to imagine how I would feel if this were my daughter. I would lose my mind. I'd also name nurses and doctors who let this happen to every media outlet in the world. I wonder how they can sleep at night.

Tragic, such a beautiful little baby.

James, London, 01/5/2012+++++++So far we've seen "Ms Stevenson said..." and "Ms Stevenson alleges..." and "Ms Stevenson felt that..." Ms Stevenson is not a doctor and has no medical knowledge so, perhaps instead of jumping to conclusions, lets hear what the inquest establishes from expert witnesses before blame is apportioned. The use of the headline about bribery was appalling when, in fact, no bribery took place. The DM is fast becoming The Sun.

I will add here, that having worked in a hospital for a number of years, I have never seen so much arrogance, laxity, laziness, incompetence, complacency, misinformation, poor communication & disregard for human life. It is a brotherhood system you cannot beat. If you stand up to challenge, you are cut down. If you don't fit in, you are cut down. You have to leave so you don't become like them. It is a rarity to find any staff that actually care about the person more than their earnings and vanity for status. I found only a few are passionate about their work for the greater good....

My 3 month old daughter was in intensive care, with a swelling to her brain - she was stable, alert and awake and fully responsive, being monitored in an uncubator for several days, and prognosis was good .....but then 'they' decided to ship her 60 miles away because they 'werent equipped to look after babies'. By the time she arrived at the next hospital, she was clinically dead on arrival not even able to breathe for herself - her brain had suddenly swelled more (when it had been slowly diminshing) and she never awoke again . It wasn' a coincidence. It was the journey that killed her. She had been fine until they loaded her into the ambulance (we had to travel separately) It was too soon to move her - they should have waited until the swelling had fully diminished (it WAS diminishing). But they wouldn't wait. The journey and moving and 2 hours of road jolting exacerbated her condition, & ended her life. Every day, 'they' make BAD decisions about people's lives.....

Very sad sorry, my thoughts are with her family. As an aside - to all the Americans berating the NHS, please be quiet about something you clearly know little about, and have probably never personally experienced.

Rest in peace little one.

@Dolittle, USA, 01/5/2012 12:53 Obama wants to model access to healthcare to the poorest people. You forgot to mention that those that have the best healthcare are those that can afford it. Wait until you have a really expensive healthcare problem and have to look up the fine print in your insurer's policies and are denied healthcare. I will NEVER have to worry about that!

A very sad story. This is what Obama wants the USAs health care system to model. Health care workers in the USA can tell you that they see people from Canada and Britian come to the US inorder to receive quality care. - Dolittle, USA, 01/5/2012 12:53 ------ Complete Fabrication, the one person the Tea Party found as an example of a Canadian seeking US treatment was a liar and a fantasist.

Can someone please explain to me why the NHS staff treat patients with horrid conditions this way? I guess it's because they don't tick the politically correct boxes.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.